Engels, Reductionism and Epigenetics: The Lysenko Debate
Pages 157-191| Published online: 27 Jan 2022
Kumar, Hari. 2022. “Engels, Reductionism and Epigenetics: The Lysenko Debate.” Marxism & Sciences 1(1):157–191. https://doi.org/10.56063/MS.2201.01108.
This article has three goals: To reprise Engels’ view of dialectical change; second to review how epigenetics challenges classical genetics and assess its tenets against those of Trofim Lysenko; finally, to consider the political rise of Lysenko. Engels viewed interconnectedness and change as key principles of nature and society, as did Marx. Eschewing a-priori schematization, both viewed theory as derived from and tested by practice. Western classical genetics and Lysenkoism took diametrically opposite forms of reductionism. Genetics ignored cell-organism interactions with the environment, adopting predeterminism; Lysenko stressed cellular roles minimizing genes. However modern epigenetics supports Engels’ rejection of an ‘either-or’ mentality. Parallel historical reductionism places Stalin in sole command of the USSR. Two intersecting reductionisms—in biology, and in political history—need updating to understand Lysenkoism.
Keywords: Engels, reductionism, epigenetics, The Lysenko Debate, Lysenkoism, Stalin.
Alemayehu, Desalegn. 2017. “Review on Impact of Plant Breeding in Crop Improvement.” Ethiopia International Journal of Research Studies in Agricultural Sciences (IJRSAS) 3: 26–35.
Altman, Arie, Longjiang Fan, Christine Foyer, Wallace Cowling, Ron Mittler, Matin Qaim, Andreas P.M. Weber, Matthew Reynolds, Rajeev K. Varshney and Alisdair Fernie. 2021. “Past and Future Milestones of Plant Breeding.” Trends in Plant Science 26(6): 530–538.
Anderson, Perry. 1987. Considerations on Western Marxism. London: Verso Books.
Austin, Christopher P. n.d. “Chromatin.” National Human Genome Research Institute. https://www.genome.gov/genetics-glossary/Chromatin
Bernal, JD. 1949. The Freedom of Necessity. London: Routeldge Kegan & Paul.
Blackledge, Paul. 2020. “Engels vs. Marx? Two Hundred Years of Frederick Engels.” Monthly Review 72(1). https://monthlyreview.org/2020/05/01/engels-vs-marx-two-hundred-years-of-frederick-engels/
Bland, W.B. 1980. “Appendix 3: ‘The Leningrad Affair’.” In Restoration of Capitalism in the Soviet Union. Wembley, London: Select Editions. https://www.marxists.org/archive/bland/1980/restoration-capitalism-soviet-union/appendix-3.htm
———. 1994. “The Historical Significance of Stalin’s ‘Economic Problems of Socialism in the USSR.” Marxist Internet Archive (MIA): Bill Bland. https://www.marxists.org/archive/bland/1994/x01/historical-significance-stalins-economic-problems-socialism-ussr.pdf
———. 1999. “Stalin: ‘The Myth and the Reality.” In The Conference Of ‘International Struggle: Marxist- Leninist. Paris. https://www.marxists.org/archive/bland/1999/x01/x01.htm
Bonasio, Roberto, Shengjiang Tu and Danny Reinberg. 2010. “Molecular Signals of Epigenetic States.” Science 330(29): 612–616. https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.1191078
Borinskaya, Svetlana A., Andrei I. Ermolaev and Eduard I. Kolchinsky. 2019. “Lysenkoism Against Genetics: The Meeting of the Lenin All-Union Academy of Agricultural Sciences of August 1948, Its Background, Causes, and Aftermath.” Genetics 212: 1–12.
Brain, Steven. 2011. Song of the Forest: Russian Forestry and Stalinist Environmentalism, 1905–1953. University Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh.
Brandenberger, David and Mikhail Zelenov. 2019. “Introduction.” In Stalin’s Master Narrative: A Critical Edition of the History of the CPSU(B)—Short Course. New Haven; Yale University Press.
Buss, Leo.W. 1983. “Processes of Evolution, Development, and the Units of Selection.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 80: 1387–1391.
Churchill, Frederick B. 1987. “From Heredity Theory to Vererbung: The Transmission Problem, 1850–1915.” Isis 78:336–364.
Crick, Francis. 1970. “Central Dogma of Molecular Biology.” Nature 227(5258): 561–563.
Danchin, Etienne, Arnaud Pocheville, Olivier Rey, Benoit Pujol and Simon Blanchet. 2019. “Epigenetically Facilitated Mutational Assimilation: Epigenetics as a Hub within the Inclusive Evolutionary Synthesis.” Biological Reviews 94: 259–282.
Danchin, Etienne, Arnaud Pocheville and Philippe Huneman. 2019. “Early in Life Effects and Heredity: Reconciling Neo-Darwinism with Neo-Lamarckism under the Banner of the Inclusive Evolutionary Synthesis.” Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences 374: 1–13.
Darwin, C. R. n.d. Notebook B Zoonomia #3: [Transmutation of species (1837-1838)]. CUL-DAR121. Transcribed by Kees Rookmaaker. Darwin Online. http://darwin-online.org.uk/content/frameset?itemID=CUL-DAR121.-&pageseq=38&viewtype=side
———. 1875. “The Variation of Animals and Plants Under Domestication.” Gutenberg Project Second Edition, Volumes One and Two. London. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/3332/3332-h/files/chap27.html
———. 1958. “Origin of Species; Chapter 1 ‘Variation under Domestication 1859’.” Mentor edition, New York 6th edition: 35.
Dawkins, Richard. 1976. The Selfish Gene. New York: Granada Publishing House.
Deichmann, Ute. 2014. “The Concept of the Causal Role of Chromosomes and Genes in Heredity and Development: Opponents from Darwin to Lysenko.” Perspectives in Biology and Medicine 57: 57–77.
Dejong-Lambert, William and Nikolai Krementsov. 2012. “On Labels and Issues: The Lysenko Controversy and the Cold War.” Journal of the History of Biology 45: 373–388.
De Winter, Willem. 1997. “The Beanbag Genetics Controversy: Towards A Synthesis of Opposing Views Of Natural Selection.” Biology and Philosophy 12: 149–184.
Dronamraju, Krishna. 2010. Haldane, Mayr, and Beanbag Genetics. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Engels, Frederick. 1936; “Letter to Marx July 14, 1858.” In Marx and Engels; Select Correspondence, edited by Donna Torr. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
———. 1987a. “Anti-Duhring.” In Marx and Engels Collected Works, Vol. 25. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
———. 1987b. “Dialectics of Nature.” In Marx and Engels Collected Works, Vol. 25. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
———. 1987c. “Preparatory writing for Anti-Duhring.” In Marx and Engels Collected Works, Vol. 25. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
Fernandez-Twinn, Denise S., Miguel Constância and Susan E. Ozanne. 2015. “Intergenerational Epigenetic Inheritance in Models of Developmental Programming of Adult Disease.” Seminars Cell & Developmental Biology 43: 85–95.
Fok, Ezio T., Laurianne Davignon, Stephanie Fancucchi and Musa M. Mhlanga. 2019. “The lncRNA Connection Cellular Metabolism and Epigenetics in Immunity.” Frontiers Immunology 9(3184): 1–11.
Foster, John Bellamy. 2020. The Return of Nature. New York: Monthly Press.
Galhardo, Rodrigo S., P. J. Hastings and Susan M. Rosenberg. 2007. “Mutation as a Stress Response and the Regulation of Evolvability.” Critical Reviews in Biochemistry and Molecular Biology 42(5): 399–435.
Getty, J. Arch, Gábor T. Rittersporn and Viktor N. Zemskov. 1993. “Victims of the Soviet Penal System in the Pre-War Years: A First Approach on the Basis of Archival Evidence.” The American Historical Review 98(4) :1017–1049.
Graham, Loren. 2016. Lysenko’s Ghost. Cambridge Mass: Harvard University Press.
Goldberg, Aaron D., C. David Allis and Emily Bernstein. 2007. “Epigenetics: A Landscape Takes Shape.” Cell 128: 635–638
Hahn, Werner G. 1982. Postwar Soviet Politics: The Fall of Zhdanov and the Defeat of Moderation 1945–53. New York: Cornell University Press.
Halfmann, Randal and Susan Lindquist. 2010. “Epigenetics in the Extreme: Prions and the Inheritance of Environmentally Acquired Traits.” Science 330: 62–64.
Harris, Jonathan. 2008. The Split in Stalin’s Secretariat, 1939-1948. Plymouth, UK: Lexington Books.
Hemberger, Myriam and Roger Pedersen. 2010. “Epigenome Disruptors.” Science 330: 598–599.
Hudson, P.S and R.H. Richens. 1946. “The New Genetics in the Soviet Union.” In Imperial Bureau of Plant Breeding and Genetics. England: Cambridge.
Hyldig-Nielson, Jens Jorgen, Erik O. Jensen, Kirsten Paludan, Ove Wiborg, Roger Garrett, Poul Jorgensen and Kjeld A. Marcker. 1982. “The Primary Structures of Two Leghemoglobin Genes from Soybean.” Nucleic Acids Research 10(2): 689–701.
Jablonka, Eva and Marion J. Lamb. 2020. Elements in the Philosophy of Biology Inheritance Systems and the Extended Evolutionary Synthesis. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108685412.
Joravsky, David. 1986. The Lysenko Affair. University of Chicago Press.
Kangal, Kaan. 2020. Friederich Engels and the Dialectics of Nature. Cham, Switzerland: Palgrave Macmillan.
Keller, Evelyn Fox. 1983. A Feeling for the Organism, The Life of Barbara McClintlock. San Francisco: W.H. Freeman.
———. 2000. The Century of the Gene. Harvard Press.
Kempe, Katja, Myroslava Rubtsova and Mario Gils. 2014. “Split-Gene System for Hybrid Wheat Seed Production.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 111: 9097–9102.
Koonin, Eugene V. 2009. “The Origin at 150: Is a New Evolutionary Synthesis in Sight?” Trends in Genetics 25(11): 473–475.
Lecourt, Dominque. 1977. Proletarian Science? The Case of Lysenko. London, UK: New Left Books.
Lenin, V.I. 1962. “Materialism and Empirocriticism.” In Lenin Collected Works Vol. 14. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
Lewin, Roger. 1982. “Can Genes Jump between Eukaryotic Species.” Science 217(4554): 41–42.
Levins, Richard and Lewontin, Richard. 1985. “The Problem of Lysenkoism.” In The Dialectical Biologist. Cambridge Mass: Harvard U Press.
Lewontin, Richard. 1992. “The Dream of the Human Genome: Doubts About the Human Genome Project.” New York Rev Books May 28, 39(10):31-40.
———. 2000. The Triple Helix: Gene Orgnanism and Environment. Harvard University Press.
Lewontin, Richard and Richard Levins. 2000. “Schmalhausen’s Law.” Capitalism, Nature and Science11(4): 103–108
Lukács, Georgy. 1993. History and Class Consciousness. New Delhi.
Lysenko, Trofim D. 1935. “History of the Problem of Vernalization.” In Agrobiology: Essays on Problems of Genetics, Plant Breeding and Seed Growing 1954. Moscow: Foreign Languages Publishing House (FLPH).
———. 1936. “Two Trends in genetics.” In Agrobiology: Essays on Problems of Genetics, Plant Breeding and Seed Growing 1954. Moscow: Foreign Languages Publishing House (FLPH).
———. 1943. “Heredity and its Variability.” In Agrobiology: Essays on Problems of Genetics, Plant Breeding and Seed Growing 1954Moscow: Foreign Languages Publishing House (FLPH).
———. 1948. “Session of Lenin Academy of Agricultural Sciences: ‘The Situation in Biological Sciences – Concluding Remarks July 31, 1948’.” In Agrobiology: Essays on Problems of Genetics, Plant Breeding and Seed Growing 1954. Moscow: Foreign Languages Publishing House (FLPH).
Marx, Karl. 1976a. “Preface to First German Edition.” Capital Vol. 1: 93, translated by Ben Fowkes. London: Pelican Books.
———. 1976b. “The Poverty of Philosophy: Response to Proudhon’s Philosophe de la misere [The philosophy of poverty] 1847.” In Marx and Engels Collected Works, Vol. 6. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
———. 1989. “Letter to Editor (Saltykov-Schedrin) of the Otecestvenniye Zapisky [Notes on the Fatherland] regarding Marx’s Critic N.K. Mihailovsky.” In Marx and Engels Collected Works, Vol. 24. Moscow: Progress Publishers.
Mayr, Ernst. 1976. Evolution and the Diversity of Life. Cambridge Mass: Belnap Press.
———. 1982. The Growth of Biological Thought. Cambridge Mass: Belnap Press.
McCagg, William O., Jr. 1978. Stalin Embattled 1943–1948. Detroit, Michigan: Wayne State University Press.
Meaney, Michael J., and Anne C. Ferguson-Smith. 2010. “Epigenetic Regulation of Neural Transcriptome: Meaning of Marks.” Nature Neuroscience 13(11): 1313–1318.
Morgan, Thomas Hunt. 1926. “Genetics and the Physiology of Development.” The American Naturalist 60: 489–515.
———. 1934. “The Relation of Genetics to Physiology and Medicine.” Nobel Lecture. https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/morgan-lecture.pdf
Mosini, Valeria. 2013. “Proteins, the Chaperone Function and Heredity.” Biology & Philosophy 28: 53–74
Noble, Raymond and Denis Noble. 2017. “Was the Watchmaker Blind? or Was She One-Eyed?” Biology 6: 47–66.
Orel, Vitezslav. 1984. Mendel. Oxford University Press.
Peterson, Erik L. (2017). The Life Organic: The Theoretical Biology Club and the Roots of Epigenetics. PA: University Pittsburgh Press.
Peng, Jamy C. and Haifan Lin. 2013. “Beyond Trosposons: The Epigenetic and Somatic Functions of The Piwi-pirna Mechanism.” Current Opinion in Cell Biology 25(2): 190–194.
Pollock, Ethan. 2006. Stalin and the Soviet Science Wars. PA: Princeton University Press.
Prinzing, Andreas, Wim A. Ozinga, Martin Brändle, Pierre-Emmanuel Courty, Françoise Hennion, Conrad Labandeira, Christian Parisod, Mickael Pihain and Igor V. Bartish. 2017. “Benefits from Living Together? Clades Whose Species Use Similar Habitats May Persist as A Result of Eco-Evolutionary Feedbacks.” The New Phytologist 213: 66–-82.
Priyadarshan, P.M. 2019. Plant Breeding: Classical to Modern. Springer.
Prusiner, Stanley B. 1995. “The Prion Diseases.” Scientific American 272: 48–51, 54–57.
Radman, Miroslav. 1999. “Enzymes of Evolutionary Change.” Nature 401: 866–869.
———. 2001. “Fidelity and Infidelity.” Nature 413: 115.
Radman, Miroslav, François Taddei and Ivan Matic. 2000. “Evolution-Driving Genes.” Research in Microbiology 151: 91–95.
Robert, Jason Scott. 2004. Embryology, Epigenesis and Evolution. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
Roll-Hansen, Nils. 1985.; “A New Perspective on Lysenko?” Annals of Science 42(3): 261–278.
———. 2015. “On the Philosophical Roots of Today’s Science Policy: Any Lessons from the ‘Lysenko Affair’?’” Studies in East European Thought 67: 91–109.
Rose, Steven P.R. 2002. “The Biology of the Future and the Future of Biology.” Journal of Molecular Biology 319: 877–884.
Rose, Steven, Leon J. Kamin and R.C. Lewontin. 1984. Not in Our Genes. Biology, Ideology and Human nature. London: Pelican Press. ;
Sandler, Iris and Laurence Sandler. 1985. “A Conceptual Ambiguity that Contributed to the Neglect of Mendel’s Paper.” History and Philosophy of the Life Sciences 7: 3–70.
Sapp, Jan. 1987. Beyond the Gene. Cytoplasmic Inheritance and the Struggle for Authority in Genetics. New York: Oxford University press.
———. 2009. “‘Just’ in Time: Gene Theory and the Biology of the Cell Surface.” Molecular Reproduction and Development 76: 903–911.
Shapiro, James A. 1999. “Genome System Architecture and Natural Genetic Engineering in Evolution.” Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 870(1): 23–25.
Sharp, Phillip A. 1994. “Split genes and RNA Splicing-Nobel lecture.” Cell 77: 805–815
Sheehan, Helena. 1993. Marxism and the Philosophy of Science – A Critical history. New Jersey: Humanities Press International.
Schlegel, Rolf H.J. 2018. History of Plant Breeding. Taylor & Francis Group: CRC Press.
Schmidt, Alfred. 2014. The Concept of Nature in Marx. London Verso Books.
Smocovitis, V.B. 1992. “Unifying Biology: The Evolutionary Synthesis and Evolutionary Biology.” Journal of the History of Biology 25: 1–65;
Soyfer, Valery N. 1994. Lysenko and the Tragedy of Soviet Science. New Jersey: Rutgers University press.
Stahl, Titus. 2018. “Georg [György] Lukács.” In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, edited by Edward N. Zalta. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/spr2018/entries/lukacs/
Stalin, J.V. 1972. Marxism and Problems of Linguistics . Peking: People’s Publishing House.
Stegemann, Sandra and Ralph Bock. 2009. “Exchange of Genetic Material Between Cells in Plant Tissue Grafts.” Science 324: 649–651.
Temin, Howard M. and Satoshi Mizutani. 1970. “RNA-dependent DNA Polymerase in Virions of Rous Sarcoma Virus.” Nature 226: 1211–1213.
Waddington, C. H. 2012. “The Epigenotype.” International Journal of Epidemiology 41(1): 10-13. https://doi.org/10.1093/ije/dyr184
Wahl, Mary E. and Andrew W. Murray. 2016. “Multicellularity Makes Somatic Differentiation Evolutionarily Stable.” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 113(30): 8362–8367.
Weaver, Ian C.G., Nadia Cervoni, Frances A. Champagne, Ana C. D’Alessio, Shakti Sharma, Jonathan R. Sekl, Sergiy Dymov, Moshe Szyf and Michael J. Meaney. 2004. “Epigenetic Programming by Maternal Behavior.” Nature Neuroscience 7(8): 847–854.
Quammen, David. 2018. The Tangled Tree. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Wang, Jing, Libo Jiang and Rongling Wu. 2017. “Plant Grafting: How Genetic Exchange Promotes Vascular Reconnection.” The New Phytologist 214: 56–65.
Woese, Carl R. and Nigel Goldenfeld. 2009. “How the Microbial World Saved Evolution from the Scylla of Molecular Biology and the Charybdis of the Modern Synthesis.” Microbiology and Molecular Biology Reviews 73: 14–21.
Weiner, Douglas R. 1999. A Little Corner of Freedom: Russian Nature Protection from Stalin to Gorbachev. Berkeley: University California Press.
Yang, Jida, Zhiming Zhang, Dawazhaxi, Bin Wang, Qiang Li, Qiaochu Yu, Xiaokun Ou and Kashif Ali. 2019. “Spatial Distribution Patterns and Intra-Specific Competition of Pine (Pinus Yunnanensis) in Abandoned Farmland under the Sloping Land Conservation Program.” Ecological Engineering 135: 17–27.
Zirkle, Conway. 1949. Death of a Science in Russia. Philadelphia: University Pennsylvania Press.